Rhetoric CFPs & TOCs

Rhetoric CFPs & TOCs
Photo: Kristoffer Trolle (creative commons)

Thursday, April 5, 2018

Burke on his Sources III

Burke on his Sources III

Thoughts of that sort were in the back of my mind- but the trend they took was most definitely influenced by Nietzsche, in such veritable philosophic battlefields as The Birth of Tragedy and The Genealogy of Morals. Nietzsche's own combativeness was in itself enough to make him realize the value of combat so far as he was concerned, in his rest- less ingenious ways of building philosophic perspectives designed to produce a "transvaluation of all values." With his astounding com- bination of madness and profound insight, he dealt with the elements of vengeance, enslavement, and tragically idealized pugnacity that he saw, rightly or wrongly (probably a bit of both) lurking beneath our words for virtues, religion, Socratic reformism. And his very style seemed to me like a constant striking of blows. Indeed, the Nietzschean mode of critique causes us to remind ourselves that even our word "virtue" is related to the Latin word vir, the man of arms-bearing age, as per the arma virumque cano on which the Aeneid begins, in con- trast with the young (puer) and the old (senex), terms that give us re- spectively "puerility" and "senility." And since he himself in his book, The Will to Power, laid such great stress upon what he calls "perspectives," on noting the element of "transvaluation" in his dart-like nomenclature I entitled the middle section of my book "Perspective by Incongruity," having in mind the two-faced or Janus-like aspects of much modern style, due to the ambiguities of the transitions which the rapid transformations of technology are forcing upon us.

From COMMUNICATION AND THE HUMAN CONDITION edited by Lee Thayer

Monday, April 2, 2018

But for these lucky accidents (by KB)


Were I not tall and suave and handsome
were I not famed for my glamorous Byronic love-affairs had not each of my books sold riotously
had not my fists made strong men cringe

did not my several conversions
enlist further hordes of followers
and did not everything I turned to
make me big money

despite my almost glorious
good health of both body and mind
how in God's name
could I through all these years
have held up and held out and held on?

Kenneth Burke

In COMMUNICATION AND THE HUMAN CONDITION edited by Lee Thayer

Burke on his Sources II

Burke on his Sources II

The neurologist I had in mind was Sherrington, who pointed to the biologic fact that during the hunting, grasping, and eating of nourish- ment, awareness is intense; but once satisfaction is attained, the organism tends towards a state of well being, relaxation, stupor, and sleep, unless some disorder of digestion still serves to stimulate aware- ness. Thus, the very equipment that serves to bring about the benign sluggishness and relaxation of satiety is in itself the essence of turbu- lence and sruggle. This could be interpreted as meaning that without the intense exercise of its "militant" powers, the organism would fall into decay.

From COMMUNICATION AND THE HUMAN CONDITION edited by Lee Thayer

Wednesday, March 28, 2018

John Berger: I’m no longer observing them, they are observing me.

John Berger meditating on natural beauty and political action, from Confabulations
https://www.newstatesman.com/2014/12/swimming-and-seeing
I swim on my back and look up at the sky through the framed glass roof. A vivid blue with white cirrus clouds at an altitude, I’d guess, of about 5,000 metres. (The Latin for “curl” is cirrus.) The curls slowly shift, join, separate as the clouds drift in the wind. I can measure their drift thanks to the roof frame; otherwise it would be hard to notice it.
The movement of the curls apparently comes from inside the body of each cloud, not from an applied pressure; you think of the movements of a sleeping body. 
This is probably why I stop swimming, and put my hands behind my head and float. My big toes just break through the surface. The water below holds me. 
The longer I gaze at the curls the more they make me think of wordless stories, wordless stories like the stories fingers may tell, but in fact here stories told by minuscule ice crystals in the silence of the blue. 
Yesterday I read in the press that 20 Palestinians in their homes were blown to pieces in Gaza, that the US has covertly despatched 300 more troops to Iraq to defend its interest in the oil refineries, that James Foley, an American journalist held hostage by Isis, was filmed during the ritual of his execution by beheading, and that 35 illegal immigrants from Afghanistan, men, women and children, were found suffocating in a shipping container on a freighter that had just crossed the North Sea to dock in London. 
The cirrus is drifting northwards towards the deep end of the pool. Afloat on my back, motionless, I watch it and chart with my eyes the pattern of its undulations. 
Then the assurance the sight offers changes. It takes me time to understand how. Slowly the change becomes evident and the assurance I receive becomes deeper. The curls of the white cirrus are observing a man afloat on his back with his hands behind his head. I’m no longer observing them, they are observing me. 

A conspiracy of orphans

From John Berger, "Confabulations," on why he writes the way he does.

From childhood, "I treated all those I encountered as if they too were orphans like me.  And I believe I still do this.
"I propose a conspiracy of orphans. We exchange winks. We reject hierarchies. All hierarchies. We take the shit of the world for granted and we exchange stories about how we nevertheless get by. We are impertinent. More than half the stars in the universe are orphan-stars belonging to no constellation. And they give off more light than all the constellation stars.
"Yes we are impertinent.  And I guess that I approach and chat up readers in the same way.  As if you too were orphans."

Sabbatical Reading: Corder on Rhetoric -- Argument is Love




Monday, March 26, 2018

Hillaire Belloc: Sharing a legend illuminates and satisfies the recipient while it amplifies the subject matter.

Reading a book about Catholicism, with an eye toward enchanting my agnostic life.
A Legend is "a story told about some real person, real virtue, or real spiritual experience, and of such a quality that it illuminates and satisfies the recipient while it amplifies and gives further substance to the matter to which it is attached." p.161 
"Legend fell out of fashion, was abused and ridiculed and at last almost lost [because] men fell into a habit of measuring everything exactly and neglecting whatever could not be measured." p.162. 
"Legend has taken a terrible revenge.  For in its absence men have been condemned to Myth, which is the dogmatic affirmation of something false." p.163 
--Hillaire Belloc, Essays of a Catholic, 1931,

It feels like the purpose of teaching in the humanities is to encourage students to connect to legends and to see their lives as legends waiting to begin.